So I have finished the Scott McCloud book and found it a very enjoyable read. I appreciate that he went through the historical background (which I discussed previously) and that he covered general theory of comics. He outlines the basic components and the many ways they can be used: a pyramid of Reality, The Picture Plane, and Meaning. The discussion of the gutter was important as well, sort of like recognizing the necessity of silence in speech or pause in song. He wants the reader to understand the place of comics in the art world, not how to create them. He talks about the variety of approaches to the comic, the different ways of showing action (or inaction) from one panel to the next. He goes into emotion, how line has a significant effect on the the reader. Sharp and angular shapes are harsh and negative, where as loose and curving lines are easier and more positive.
There is, ultimate, a whole lot to think about when writing and especially drawing a comic book that I never thought much about prior to reading this book. At the same time that the diversity in comic books is some what intimidating, it's also comforting to know that, unlike "finer" arts, the possibilities are endless, in a way. Some comics are magnificently drawn (Watchmen), some are simple cartoons (Peanuts), each are successful for different reasons, but they are both comics. Upon creating my own comic I'm excited to figure out what style works for me and to play with the techniques that McCloud discusses. I'm eager to read "Making Comics" to learn even more about construction so that I can better apply the concepts in "Understanding Comics."
Sunday, January 25, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Chelsey,
ReplyDeleteI am so glad you enjoyed UNDERSTANDING COMICS.
When you mention such concepts as "a pramid of Reality," the Picture Plan, gutter, etc., I would like you to reference the page number in McCloud's book where such concepts or terms are defined.
I liked your comparison of the concept of "gutter" to "the necessit of silence in speech or the pause in song.
The diversity of comics is almost as vast as novels. With Jeff Smith's BONE, the characters are as simply drawn as PEANUTS or POGO. WATCHMEN is much more complex. One has to really pay attention. This will be more apparent when we do break-downs of some of the WATCHMEN panels.
Good work.
Cynthia